Activist state

Why No One Is Talking About This Swing-State Senate Race That Could Determine The Balance Of Power In Washington

RALEIGH, NC—”We’re thrilled with Dave Matthews!”

Cheri Beasley, the Democratic candidate for the US Senate in North Carolina, is doing her best to rally the party’s base. It’s a Tuesday night in the state capitol, and hundreds of white, college-educated and Gen-X millennials are genuinely excited to see Dave Matthews perform at this DNC-sponsored event exactly two weeks before. mid-terms of 2022. (Matthews, 55, is best known for posting a hit album several weeks before the 1994 midterms.)

The near-full crowd becomes restless, nursing local IPAs, as the candidate lays out a few talking points about all that’s “at stake” in this election: abortion rights, climate change, “safe communities.” Whatever that means. (from Beasley registration as a state Supreme Court justice and his willingness to associate with radicals”fund the policeActivists suggest a broad definition of the term.) His abbreviated speech does not mention inflation but concludes on an inspiring note: “Things can get worse.”

Matthews takes the stage. The multi-multi-millionaire understands these middle-aged professionals and their bespoke anxieties. He semi-coherently rants about Republicans, denouncing their supporters as bigoted monsters. He wonders why we can’t just get along. With great privilege comes great guilt. “I’m fine, but I don’t want to feel bad,” he complains.

The crowd goes wild.


Most Americans have never heard of Cheri Beasley or her GOP opponent, Rep. Ted Budd, a gun store owner in Davie County, outside Winston-Salem, elected for the first time in 2016. Both candidates are running to succeed Sen. Richard Burr (R., NC), who is retiring after three terms. It’s a race that could determine which party controls the US Senate for the second half of President Joe Biden’s first (and likely last) term, but the national media is paying no attention.

It’s almost certainly by design. Both parties nominated generic candidates unlikely to make headlines. No famous doctors. No fat stroke victims in cargo shorts talking with the coherence of a teenage beauty queen explain (and embody) the failures of our educational system. No eccentric football legends betraying the black community by running against a Democrat. No 2024 contenders who could disrupt former President Donald Trump’s path to the GOP nomination.

Beasley is not a self-proclaimed media darling like Stacey Abrams. Budd was offensive by the Lincoln Project for neglecting “the people of Wisconsin”. He doesn’t provoke national reporters and other Democratic activists into fits of convulsive rage like JD Vance and Ron DeSantis do. Still, Ohio and Florida aren’t really swing states compared to North Carolina. In 2020, the same year Trump won the state by 1.3 percentage points, Gov. Roy Cooper (D., NC) was comfortably re-elected. Sen. Thom Tillis (R., NC) likely would have lost his seat the same year had Democrat Cal Cunningham not been nabbed cheat on his wife a few weeks before polling day.

In other words, the outcome of this race will be a reasonably accurate reflection of the national mood, which is why Budd is likely to win. He led almost every poll of at least 3 percentage points since early September. FiveThirtyEight give him a 80 percent chance of victory. In a midterm cycle under a struggling Democratic president, being a running generic Republican in a swing state is a pretty good gig. The stump speech, if you can stick to the script, practically writes itself.

“If you like paying more for everything, then you should vote for [Cheri] Beasley and Joe Biden because they did this,” Rick Scott, chairman of the Republican National Senate Committee, told a group of Budd supporters last month at a GOP community center in Greensboro. “You want a good economy ? Do you want great schools? Want low crime? Want a country people can be proud of? So go vote for Ted Budd.”

Budd, who won Trump’s endorsement but managed to avoid the baggage that comes with it, much like Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R., Va.) in 2021, asks attendees to raise their hands if they think the country is on the wrong track and immediately makes a joke at the expense of journalists who have given up. He’s not afraid to make controversial statements such as “parents…should have a say in the upbringing of children.” He talks about inflation “in real terms,” ​​as opposed to the academic pundits you often see on cable news. “To pay twice as much for gasoline…for a lot of people, it’s a crisis,” he says.

The candidate quotes one of his campaign ads, titled “The tale of two carts“, which highlights the rising cost of groceries since Biden took office. “You are forced to make tough decisions because Joe Biden made bad decisions,” Budd says in the ad.” Biden’s reckless spending has given us record inflation that is crushing working families in North Carolina…I’m running for the Senate to stop his spending and end this recession.”

Another campaign ad, “Who is to blame?“quote a Free Washington Beacon report on Beasley’s record of leniency toward pedophiles as chief justice of the state’s Democratic-controlled Supreme Court. The Senate Leadership Fund, a super PAC aligned with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.), covered the airwaves with ads tackle She’s also soft on crime and highlighting his support for Biden’s economic agenda.

Judith Bleiberg, a retired flight attendant and part-time fitness instructor from Greensboro, says Free tag that Budd’s campaign touches on “every issue that concerns all Americans right now” – inflation and the economy first, followed by schools, crime and immigration. “I’m a senior, and my retirement savings, along with the stock market, are collapsing,” she says. “Prices are going up, gas prices are going up. People can’t do that. Oh yeah, maybe the elites and Hollywood [and Dave Matthews] or whatever it is, but your average person – how are they going to cope if this continues?”


Like most Democrats leading this cycle, Beasley struggled to articulate a convincing answer to this question. She tries to run away of Biden as she ran against the US Congress, where her opponent is in the minority. She has talking points about how “Washington has failed families here in North Carolina.” She says it’s “time for a change” and insists “Congress can fix” the inflation problem. It’s unclear how keeping Democrats in charge will accomplish this.

The Democratic Party has spent nearly a third of a billion dollars on abortion campaign ads this cycle, compared to just $31 million on ads dealing with inflation. Beasley’s campaign is hardly an exception. A super PAC aligned with Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D., NY) fall $4 million to run an abortion-themed TV ad in all major media markets during the final weeks of the race. The State Party clutters suburban mailboxes with flyers denouncing Budd as a “dangerous” anti-choice zealot who “doesn’t care about women’s lives.”

Beasley tried to embrace what passes for moderation these days. For example, she is one of the only statewide Democrats who has not endorsed a limitless approach to abortion. She wants to restore the “protections and restrictions” under deer v. Wade but also insists that “women will die” if Budd is elected. Part of the problem is that to get national exposure and solicit donations from #Resistance liberals, Beasley has to appear on MSNBC and answer questions from lunatics like Lawrence O’Donnell and Joy-Ann Reid, who are convinced that the abortion and January 6 are the main concerns of voters.

Before interviewing Beasley on Oct. 20, Reid moderated a thoughtful discussion about how “Republicans have … doubled down on the idea of ​​codifying white nationalism” by making black voting “literally illegal.” She then asked Beasley if she felt “enlightened” by polls showing that voters aren’t as concerned about abortion as they are about rising living costs.

The following day, Beasley appeared on the “Higher Learning” podcast with hosts Van Lathan and Rachel Lindsay. In the segment leading up to the interview, Lathan denounced Ron DeSantis as a “punk motherfucker” and “overseer…who wants to punish people for setting an example for the rest of the plantation slaves.” Because “America’s favorite pastime [is] blame the ns.” Beasley stuck to her talking points, which are unlikely to inspire anyone not already inclined to support her, especially those on inflation.

“In the greatest country in the world, people shouldn’t have trouble figuring out how to pay for expensive groceries, school supplies, or drugs, and Congress really needs to act,” the candidate said. “TThe Senate really needs to act boldly to make a difference for people here in North Carolina and across the country. (Background: His party controls both houses of Congress and the White House.)

Beasley is black, in case you were wondering. She won the Senate primary after state legislator Jeff Jackson, a generic white man, dropped out of the race to run for a newly created House seat. In 2020, Democratic leaders were widely criticized for spending millions of dollars against black candidates running in major Senate primaries, including in North Carolina. “Senator Schumer, for some reason, didn’t want an African American to run for the Senate in North Carolina,” said Erica Smith, a black lawmaker in the state who lost the 2020 primary to Cunningham, the failure of the womanizer.

A cynical observer might conclude that Schumer never thought a Democrat could win this year in North Carolina, which hasn’t elected a Democratic senator since 2008, when Barack Obama became the first Democrat to win the state. since Jimmy Carter. Nonetheless, the Democratic leader wanted credit for supporting diversity, so Beasley got the nod. Perhaps the Democratic Party is more virtuous in this regard. Maybe not.

In any event, when the midterm elections are finally decided, Schumer and his allies will (most likely) have to reckon with an increasingly popular Republican party among minority and working-class voters, and an increasingly popular Democratic party. more concerned with the apprehensions of fans of Dave Matthews lamenting their good fortune on a Tuesday night in Raleigh.